Panel Discussion – Music and Robotics

By Henk van Engelen

JUST TYPED ALONG WITH THE SESSION SO EVERYTHING IS STILL PRETTY MESSY, NO LINKS INCLUDED AND POSSIBLE FAULTS ARE MY OWN RATHER THAN THE SPEAKERS,…

panelists: Trimpin, Godfried-Willem Raes, Gordon Monahan, en Jaques Remus
http://www.gordonmonahan.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trimpin
http://www.mecamusique.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godfried-Willem_Raes

Q: Is musical robotics a novelty or something really serious?
JR – gives you a orchestra without paying musicians
- it’s about making acoustic music with electronics
- it’s about building interfaces for real instruments, not synthesizers and computer music.
- To have pure acoustic sound: music made for machines but that no loudspeaker can reproduce and no people can make
GWR – It’s not something new but what is new is the programmability: this is a real novilty
GM – we’re inventors that other musician pick up,.. there is a fine line then between us and the other musicians
T – All composers composed for machines but it was not accepted and it never came to the public. But all composers composed for it.
Q: there is a current explosion of interest, at least here in NY,.. s this shortlived or the future?
GWR – I don’t feel an explosion: there are few people doing serious work in this field. There is a lot o amateurism: In order for somthing to be a robot it must have some form of sensor. either of it’s internal state, or more advanced: a sensor for there environment in which they ‘live’. That makes it into a robot. It’s not just something mechanical.
Q: well there is artbot etc and some more teaching in the field
GWR: I’m sure it’s gonna grow
JR – We’re a lot of things at the time: multidimensional artists: time (music), space (visual), performers (stage)
T – interdisciplinary institutions in the university failed because the different departments didn’t understand each other.
Q: tips to get started
GWR – get the book “the art of electronics”, also get a good workshop
T – start simple,.. with small things and then grow,.. do it all yourself, get nothing “off the shelf”, be patient
JR – first a dream, then the tools
GM – you can also buy things of the shelf,.. for me it works
GWR: get the tool for the purpose in stead of turning the tool into the purpose
Q: How do you make it so human?
QWR: there is nothing as human as a machine

Leave a Reply